On an early track of her latest CD, Whitney Houston poignantly sings "I want you to love me/Like I never left." Having listened twice through now, I can wholeheartedly claim that I still do. Which is not to say that "I Look to You" is a great album, or even a good one. But, hold on, it's not really a bad one, either. For the most part it plays out like a greatest hits collection in that we pretty much know what's coming next. Early bubblegum ("Million Dollar Bill") is followed by some power ballads (like the title track), followed by some mild flirtations with electronic hip-hop ("For the Lovers" for example). Houston is playing squarely in her comfort zone here, but she's earned it, no? Not every album can, should or needs to reinvent the wheel. The only true misfire is a disco (yes, you heard it here first) version of the Donny Hathaway classic "A Song for You." It's bizarre, to say the least, unlikely to be remembered as one of that song's best renditions.
And how is Houston's voice? A little heavier and thicker than it was, frankly, but still quite strong and supple. Perhaps the single most telling indication that something's changed is that every song stays solidly in the same key from beginning to end. A couple of times I thought, "Here comes the old Whitney Houston kick-ass modulation"...but it never happened. OK, so now we know, we can all move on.
Neither a triumphant return to form nor a crash-and-burn disaster, "I Look to You" is the uneventful return of an old friend. I, for one, am just fine with that.