The release of 2007's Puzzle saw Kilmarnock's Biffy Clyro garnering an evergrowing
fanbase. Featuring driving, angular rock and some truly anthemic choruses, it appeared to mark their preparation for rightful ascent into the mainstream consciousness.
Perhaps in an attempt to reassure the Biffy 'faithful' (a fervently elitist group refusing to acknowledge any of the band's musical output post-Infinity Land) looking for another `Vertigo of Bliss', record company hype would have us believe Only Revolutions marks a departure from the more commercial leanings of Puzzle. A puzzling (no pun intended) claim then considering that - if anything - it sees Simon Neil and his crew travel further down that path than ever before.
The last 18 months have seen reassuring glimpses of brilliance in the form of
the album's first two singles 'Mountains' and, more recently, `That Golden
Rule'. Both are standout tracks, yet strangely at odds with an album equal
parts pure awesomeness and missed opportunity. It is either testament to the band's strengths or representative of flawed genius that they feel confident enough to relegate such gems as `Time Jazz' and `Eyelids' (That Golden Rule EP) to mere B sides. Yet it is precisely this apparent lack of focus that has produced much criticism in the past, viewed by many as an inability to recognise standout tracks from their own (admittedly prolific) catalogue.
Opener `The Captain' is perhaps the band's most obvious attempt at a hit
single yet, a mantra-like chorus held aloft on a wave of stabbing horns. Met
with more than a little derision by the internet faithful on its release as a
single, it's a definite grower and sure to get fists pumping at festivals across
the land next year. Perhaps the album's biggest surprise comes with the arrival early on of `Bubbles'. A remarkably uplifting gem, it marks Biffy's growing mastery of melody and songwriting dynamics on a track surely destined for future classic status.
`Born on a Horse' boasts an elastic bassline that would be at home on either
of the last two Muse albums. Despite Simon Neil's intriguing, trademark angular riffs and offbeat-but-ever-so-slightly-funky time signature, it ultimately fails to get off the ground. In an album seemingly in thrall to the mystery of
relationships (the title Only Revolutions is drawn from Mark Z. Danielewski's
novel of the same name - a story that explores the nature of relationships)
`Shock Shock' is all relationship angst and raw fury as Neil spits "I don't even
know what the f*ck we're still arguing about".
Puzzle also marked a newfound strength for the band in ballad territory,
featuring crowd favourites `Folding Stars' and `As Dust Dances'. Revolutions
continues this trend with `Many of Horror', a sincere, heartfelt pledge sure to
see lighters aloft live. The album picks up pace towards its close with the
unbridled optimism of tracks such as the rather oddly-titled `Cloud of Stink'
during which Neil invites us to "Swing if you wanna swing" followed by `Whorses' and its relentlessly infectious blend of swelling melody and driving
beats (the less said about `Know Your Quarry' the better).
Album closer `Sky Demon' is a rather paint-by-numbers exercise in versechorus-
verse blandness, ending the album on a strangely disconnected note. It is precisely this lack of cohesiveness that represents Only Revolutions' biggest problem. For every standout track (of which there are many) there is simply uninspired filler waiting in the wings. The resulting whole comes across as confused, inspired and chaotic all at once - making for a strangely disaffecting listen.
Here's to the next album then boys.