Thursday Throwdown: Bright Eyes' The People's Key
Feb, 17 2011
Each Thursday we bring you strong opinions from the web’s most respected music critics in a series we like to call the Thursday Throwdown. This week, we bring you the newest, and possibly last, record for Conor Oberst’s band Bright Eyes. The People’s Key, which came out on Tuesday, is the first release from the band since 2007.
American Songwriter’s Matt Fink wrote a poetic review of the record, giving it 4 out of 5 stars, calling The People’s Key “the sound of a songwriter and a band coming into their own.” Fink goes on to say, “Oberst has never sounded so confident as a vocalist and so willing to create ear candy as a songwriter… these arrangements are polished to perfection but lose none of their conceptual heft in the process.”
While Fink Praises The People’s Key, Andrew Perry from The Telegraph UK has a different take. He gives the record a paltry 2 out of 5 asterisks (instead of stars?) saying, “This first album in four years affects the air of a grand conceptual statement, complete with portentous spoken-word passages. But ultimately it amounts to two decent tunes in the singer-songwriter pop idiom, padded out with angsty filler and hot air.”
Take a listen and head over to our Facebook to let us know if you agree with Fink or Perry.
-Erin O.
Permalink