Madonna's biggest album in worldwide sales, TRUE BLUE was a huge smash in the US as well. The album spent five weeks at #1 on the Hot 200 and has sold 20 million copies worldwide, with a hefty seven million copies (that's Platinum 7 times over) sold in the US alone. Madonna took a very active role in producing the record, and had a hand in writing all nine songs. Her singing voice was also noticeably stronger this time around, with more control and emotion. This was also the first full-length recording where the pitch of Madonna's vocals were not mechanically altered, leaving the album with sexier, more adult-sounding aura than her previous albums.
Madonna's vocals have rarely sounded as confident and impassioned as on the semi-controversial hit "Papa Don't Preach" (#1 Pop, #16 Adult Contemporary, #4 Dance), during which her intense delivery convinces us that this song really matters. She gives a similarly effective vocal on the smash fourth single "Open Your Heart" (#1 Pop, #1 Dance), which is a terrific dance track, despite some unimaginative lyrics ("I hold the lock, you hold the key"). Madonna's incredibly determined performance (and the song's blistering rock-infused sound) makes "Open Your Heart" a standout. It does not matter that her strained voice sometimes sounds raspy and off-key, because when she sings, "don't try to run, I can keep up with you," the listener can really feel her determination. The conviction in her performances are more evident in these two songs than in anywhere else in her entire career, and it single-handedly makes both songs classics. These are also the only two songs on the album that Madonna co-wrote with outside songwriters, she collaborated with mainstays Patrick Leonard and Steve Bray on the remaining seven tracks.
One of those Ciccone-Leonard compositions remains one of Madonna's best-written song: the pensive smash "Live To Tell" (#1 Pop, #1 Adult Contemporary). Originally featured in the film AT CLOSE RANGE, "Live To Tell" is a complex ballad which Madonna lends even more maturity and intensity to with her still-yearning-after-all-these-years performance. There were some critics (including ROLLING STONE magazine) who argued that "Live To Tell" was a rewrite of Joni Mitchell's simple folk ballad "Both Sides Now," but I honestly don't hear it that way at all. As a matter of fact, it remains Madonna's finest moment as a songwriter, in my opinion. Her seemingly newfound maturity is also present in the vivid "La Isla Bonita" (#4 Pop, #1 Adult Contemporary) and scorching "White Heat", both also written with Leonard.
Leonard and Bray are obviously key figures in Madonna's mid-eighties success, and together the three of them manage to even make some otherwise flimsy songs work much better than they should. For example, Madonna, Leonard, and Steve Bray pool their considerable talents on the obvious-but-fun "Where's The Party," while the irresistible Ciccone-Bray title track (#3 Pop, #6 Dance) is paper-thin, but completely adorable. Unfortunately, the remaining two songs are shockingly weak - TRUE BLUE definitely isn't as consistent as MADONNA or LIKE A VIRGIN. Madonna and Leonard really fumble with the embarrassingly saccharine "Love Makes The World Go Round," which is so sugary that it may give listeners cavities upon listening. Madonna and Steve Bray also really hit rock-bottom with the grating "Jimmy Jimmy," which is quite possibly the most annoying number that Madonna ever committed to vinyl.
The album would probably play much better if the weaker numbers weren't sequenced right at the end, however, even then, TRUE BLUE'S parts are still greater than the sum. Even though it has some of Madonna's best work, the album really never plays as a satisfying whole. Where Nile Rodgers' inventive production unified much of LIKE A VIRGIN and carried the listener through that album's few weak moments, TRUE BLUE'S multiple producers (including Madonna, Leonard, and Bray) give the album a patchwork feel that makes the filler really stand out. Even the terrific singles don't really seem to belong on the same disc. However, TRUE BLUE contains so many big hits (it's nine tracks include five Top Five hits) that it's flaws won't bother most listeners. Plus the end result is still quite good, and it gives you a taste of the maturity that was to come three years later with LIKE A PRAYER.